I have reviewed several other Charlotte Tilbury Eyeliners and lipliners. I just added two new colors. So this is more for swatching and I’ll link you to the previous reviews.
The Rock ‘n’ Kohl Iconic Liquid Eye Pencil in Eye Cheat is an off white cream color to use for lining the inner rim to make you look more rested and awake. Check out the previous eye pencil review here. I like having a color like this in a long last style pencil as when I have tried these eye brightening pencils in the past, they are either too white or wear off in 2 hours. It is not shimmery. I have nothing like it to swatch and compare it to.
The lipliners are nice, they last average time like MAC but feel moister on. Check out that review here. Kiss ‘N’ Tell is a basic bright red. It’s on the left, and I compared it to MAC Cherry and Brick Lip Pencils.
L to R: MAC Brick, MAC Cherry, Charlotte Tilbury Kiss ‘N’ Tell, Charlotte Tilbury Eye Cheat.